The Virginia Supreme Court rejected the redistricting map for Democrats
Former Virginia Attorney General Jason Miyares explains why the Virginia Supreme Court’s decision to strike down the Democratic Redistricting map ‘was a legal victory. Miyares notes that the proposed map would have shifted power significantly to the Democrats, citing the court’s insistence on sticking to the state’s constitutional amendment plan.
NEWNow you can listen to Fox News articles!
The Virginia Democrats’ push back was meant to close the gap. Instead, it is resolved after a costly court defeat—causing a growing blame game within the party.
A massive effort to redraw congressional maps, funded by tens of millions of dollars and political capital, brought brief success on paper. But in a 4-3 decision, the Virginia Supreme Court struck down the maps, citing legal deficiencies, and forced a redrawing—erasing those benefits.
Democrats are left debating whether party leaders ignored legal warnings and pushed a strategy that was always in danger of collapse.
DAVID MARCUS: VIRGINIA DEMOCRATIC DISAPPEARS IN $70M MARKET NOW CRYING
In retrospect, critics say the outcome was avoidable. Republicans have called for an earlier judicial review before votes and spending, a move they say would have made clear that the maps are legal.
Democrats have moved on anyway, betting the strategy will catch on.
“Violating the Virginia Constitution and breaking the law to advance your political power is wrong,” said Rep. Jen Kiggans, R-Va., in a statement sent to The Hill. “It was like that [Democratic Gov.] Abigail Spanberger and every other Democrat in Virginia would have done irreparable damage to our democracy and disenfranchised millions of Virginians. “
The Spanbergers say legal concerns were raised early and not fully listened to, pointing to state lawmakers for moving forward. Lawmakers and other Democrats argue that the lawsuit was inevitable and that the maps were protected.
DEMS USED FOR POWER NOW FACE BACKLASH AS EXPENSES CONTINUE IN NY, VIRGINIA
Virginia Gov. Abigail Spanberger delivers a response to President Donald Trump’s State of the Union address. (Steve Helber/Reuters)
The dispute reflects a wide division within the party over how aggressively to pursue redistricting. Some Democrats say such efforts are necessary to fight Republican-led maps across the country.
“I feel like the system is broken, but let’s be clear. The Republicans have started an arms race that is redistricting,” said Rep. Jason Crow, D-Colo., told Fox News Digital in an earlier interview. “So the Democrats are left with nothing but to level the playing field for democracy.”
“Look, in a perfect world, we wouldn’t have politics,” said Rep. Christian Menefee, D-Texas, added. “But because we don’t live in that world, we have to fight fire with fire.”
However, others are not straightforward to blame.
“I put all this down to the Democrats,” said Rep. Marc Veasey, D-Texas, argued that the party failed to respond strongly to previous GOP redistricting efforts and is now facing the consequences.
CLICK HERE TO DOWNLOAD THE FOX NEWS PROGRAM
Voters attend the Arlington Democrats’ redistricting party during a special election in Arlington, Va., Tuesday, April 21, 2026. (Valerie Plesch/Bloomberg)
Fallout comes at a critical time.
A federal raid on May 6 at the office of a powerful member of parliament added to the sense of instability, while former Governor L. Douglas Wilder suggested that the upheaval would give Spanberger an opportunity to reset and impose discipline on a still-broken political operation.
The episode underscores the growing role of the courts in deregulation—and the dangers of pushing legal boundaries into dangerous territory, with potential implications for controlling Virginia’s congressional delegation.
In retrospect, even with the narrow 4-3 decision, it’s a steep figure: nearly $70 million and a large portion of Spanberger’s political capital was spent on a campaign that won the battle but lost the war.
Democrats are left to fix not just what went wrong — but who is responsible.
Fox News Digital’s Leo Briceno contributed to this report.
